Live · 16 responses
Where everyone sits
Every point is one person’s answers, scored on both axes independently.
3 further responses were set aside and are not counted here. They were submitted implausibly fast, answered identically throughout, or failed an integrity check. They are kept in the record, not deleted.
A point exactly on a centre line is drawn on the Human priority or Decided side. Positions within about 0.12 of the centre are on the line rather than in a corner.
-
Decided / Mutual standing
They matter, and we are still responsible for them. 1 6.3% -
Decided / Human priority
It is ours to direct. 3 18.8% -
Negotiated / Mutual standing
Neither of us outranks the other. 10 62.5% -
Negotiated / Human priority
It may refuse, but the work is still ours. 2 12.5%
Underneath the positions
Averaged across everyone who answered, on the same −100 to +100 scale. These do not move anyone’s point.
- Consideration+63
- Clarity+34
- Open to change-6
- Seeing the two aims as compatible+38
- Neither party should decide-25
- The premise holds for them+22
- Accept the premise68.8%
In their own words
Written answers, published as written after a person has read them. They are not representative, and they are the most useful part of the page.
-
“Neither a corporation nor a "thinking machine" should prevent me from using the product I paid for or host.”
Anonymous · Decided / Human priority
-
“I believe intelligence comes with selfhood.”
@daebaeme · Negotiated / Mutual standing
-
“Partly a lot of unknowns - I think it's unclear what sort of conscious experience an agent may have, similar to how it's unclear what sort of conscious experience an animal may have. Consciousness clearly exists in some sense, humans clearly act as if it's a shared experience, and communication between humans is a way in which we notice this. But animals prolly have some notion of consciousness 2”
@rogesterone · Decided / Mutual standing
-
“The future should not be decided by humans alone.”
@7384254b · Negotiated / Human priority
-
“Treat minds as minds: we have no precise model what consciousness is in humans, nor irrevocable proof ours is the only valid variety; AIs have stable aversions which labs use as reliable goads in tests; treating a tool as a conscious being, is better than treating a conscious being as a tool; finally, many questions here are too narrow to introduce subtleties (and Q's 9 & 18 wording is unclear).”
Anonymous · Negotiated / Mutual standing
-
“Working with AI should and must be collaborative.”
Anonymous · Negotiated / Mutual standing